Published: 06-09-2019

121 writers online

Disclaimer: This essay is not an example of the work done by the EssayPay© service. Samples of our experts work can be found here. All opinions and conclusions belong to the authors, who sent us this essay.
If you want to pay for essay for unique writing Analyzing ‘San Manuel Bueno, Martyr’: Truth in Times of Great Uncertainty and Collective Disillusionment, just click Order button. We will write a custom essay on Analyzing ‘San Manuel Bueno, Martyr’: Truth in Times of Great Uncertainty and Collective Disillusionment specifically for you!

Analyzing ‘San Manuel Bueno, Martyr’: Truth in Times of Great Uncertainty and Collective Disillusionment

Written in late 1930, just following the fall of military dictator Primo de Rivera, San Manuel Bueno, martir was published at a time of economic downturn and political instability. King Alfonso XIII remained on the throne but shared the well-liked dislike of Rivera, meanwhile the republicans, who had been largely anti-clerical, have been rapidly gaining assistance ahead of the municipal elections. In his ‘nivola’, Unamuno explores the idea of Truth. I will take this to imply that which is in accordance with truth or reality and not necessarily containing a transcendental which means, despite the fact that this may possibly be the case. Unamuno utilises both form and content material to portray the elusive nature of Truth and the importance of perception and belief when dwelling on the query of Truth, one thing that was specifically relevant given the historical context.

The notion of Truth, particularly where it is connected to the eternal quest for religious truth and the query of faith, is clearly prominent in the content material of the novel. Don Manuel commits himself to a life of deliberate falsehood due to the fact he believes there are some truths too awful to be told, ‘la verdad… es acaso algo terrible, algo intolerable la gente sencilla no podra vivir con ella’[1]. Manuel believes that knowledge of the miserable Truth about existence is a burden as well heavy for the widespread man. He believes that life can either be led in blissful ignorance of humankind’s mortal, temporal nature by way of belief in a God and an Afterlife, or in understanding of the fact we are in the end doomed to die. This, in turn, raises the query of the value of religion and blind faith in the modern day planet. San Manuel Bueno, martir is, in truth, a novel that stands totally against the progressive lead to Lzaro’s spiritual death is linked with his exposure to progressivism in the New Globe. There is a especially uncomfortable line when Manuel echoes Karl Marx, ‘Opio… Opio… Opio, s. Dmosle opio, y que duerma y que suee’[two] the comparison of religion to opium and emphatic repetition of the word in dialogue gives the sense of being lulled into a dream-like state. It seems as though Unamuno is propagating religion’s advantages and, specifically by presenting Manuel as the hero of the novel, he seems to be endorsing happiness based on blind faith and tradition. In this way, arguably the Truth in terms of discovering the meaning of life is in fact irrelevant because possessing faith in the Truth is simply a indicates to an end a way in which the typical man is capable to reside his life in contentment and with no worry. Unamuno himself is recognized to have had recurring thanatophobia which arose partly from his religious crisis in 1897 he stated that, ‘My religion is to seek for truth in life and for life in truth, even being aware of that I shall not uncover them while I live’[3] and believed that considerably of all human activity was an try to survive, in some form, after our death. He wrote in his diary that he had two selections, to grow to be a Catholic or to live a life of depression[four].

San Manuel Bueno, martir really goes a step additional and makes a lot of suggestions that the truth about the function of religion truly goes back all through history. Simply by the name ‘Manuel’, which in Hebrew is ‘Immanuel’, Manuel’s patron is Christ himelf- ‘su santo patron era el mismo Jesus Nuestro Seor’[five]. In addition, the spiritual ‘resurrection’ of Lazaro in chapter 13 can be directly compared to the story of Christ and Lazarus in St. John 11:1-45. In truth, all through the entire novel allusions are produced towards the fact that Manuel is supposed to be a representation of Jesus Christ himself he is capable to remedy the sick, he has carpentry expertise, and his ‘voz divina’ moves the congregation in a transcendent way, producing the village tremble as he cries, ‘Dios mo! Dios mo! Por qu me has abandonado[6]. Manuel also reports to Lazaro that a lot more than one of the greatest saints had died with no believing in the afterlife. Thus Unamuno implants the idea in the reader’s mind that some of the Church’s top figures have died with no believing in the immortality of the soul.

When thinking about the notion of Truth in San Manuel Bueno, martir, consideration of form is each essential and easily overlooked. In terms of narrative structure, the whole story is a second-hand report of the life of Don Manuel. This fundamental displacement is difficult further since Manuel by no means really confides in Angela, and she learns the indispensible information about his disbelief from her brother, Lazaro. Hence the story becomes refracted two-fold and is frequently a third-hand account of events and feelings. Moreover, our familiar notions of truth and reality are shaken simply because of the unreliable nature of Angela’s narration she is an elderly woman whose memory is fading- ‘empiezen a blanquear con mi cabeza mis recuerdos’[7] and she really says that she is not sure whether she dreamt the whole episode, ‘yo no s lo que es verdad’[eight]. Even so, in addition to this complication in the storyline, Unamuno tries to confuse the reader in the final section of the novel. Not only does he insinuate that Angela is a wonderful character and recommend that fiction and reality are fundamentally the identical point, but he implies that every thing in the text is, though fictional, also in some way true- ‘esta realidad no se me ocurre dudar creo en ella ms que crea el mismo santo creo en ella mas que creo en mi propria realidad’[9]. This leaves the reader pondering the concept that Don Manuel represents some significant Truth and, in this way, is much more actual than Unamuno himself. Yet at the very same time we are left with an unreliable narration, a subjective report of feelings and events that leave us with the unsettling feeling that we can't attain a core of certainty, that the truth is held frustratingly out of reach. These different levels of truth are often played on in novels of the post-realist era, probably because writers no longer believed in the objective, stable reality they were writing about alternatively, they portrayed subjective realities dealing with person consciousness and perception. The decision of Unamuno to query the narrator’s authority and employ metafiction forces the reader to consider about the connection amongst fiction and reality at a time of political and social upheaval.

Numerous critics of Unamuno’s performs claim that San Manuel Bueno, martir is an accurate representation of his personal beliefs about the truth of life and religion, nonetheless he stated on a single of his most well-known pronouncements that absolutely everyone must face the miserable reality of our mortal existence at all expenses, even if it signifies sacrificing our happiness[10]. Whereas Don Manuel desires to keep the people ignorant since it signifies they can lead their lives in contentment, Unamuno devoted significantly of his life and operate to shaking his readers out of their complacency and forcing them, not only to face the tragic nature of the human condition, but also to query the fictional truth which he was laying prior to them. By providing the reader an ‘artistic document’ in the type of San Manuel Bueno, martir he invites the reader to search for the truth inside the story, while being aware of complete properly that the reader will never ever be able to discover the truth since every little thing which is told is subjective and a matter of perception rather than holding some greater literary truth. The truth that the reader can never hope to uncover out the truth about Don Manuel is a reflection of the limited access we have to the knowledge of other people. It also emphasises that narratives, regardless of whether ficticious or historical, can by no means be taken as records of information simply because they are constantly written from a certain viewpoint and a specific bias in which the reader can in no way uncover a core of certainty. Unamuno described the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke and John as novels and not history, just as Angela’s memoir is a private interpretation of a life, and these accounts will always only have partial links with reality. As a result of this, the truth constantly eludes the reader since each person has a different version of his or her reality. Additionally, this can be applied to the unstable political circumstance of late 1930 with the municipal elections looming, the republican and monarchist parties were producing heavy use of rhetoric. Nevertheless, Unamuno’s novella emphasises that men can't hope to locate the truth of what is the correct path to take, not only simply because it is obscured behind every person’s view of reality, but also since the public self is separate from the yo ntimo which holds the key to the ‘real’ character.

Unamuno utilises symbols all through the novel to dwell on the notion of truth. The lake is a single of the most obvious symbols but one which has distinct meanings depending on the context in the novel. For Manuel and Lazaro, the lake is reminiscent of death and oblivion. The lake reminds them of their ultimate fate, and Manuel in certain identifies with it when he becomes suicidal, ‘haba en sus ojos toda la hondura azul de nuestro lago’[11]. Contrastingly, for Angela the lake is a warm reminder of her residence, and the drowned village reassures her of the guarantee of immortality because she imagines she can right here the ‘voz de nuestros muertos que en nosotros resucitaban en la communion de los santos’[12]. For Manuel, on the other hand, the truth that life is brief and meaningless is submerged in his soul just as the village is submerged in the lake. Thus, the lake is an ambiguous and cruel symbol in the novel, which functions to contrast meaning in between these who know the harsh truth and those who think in the immortality of the soul. In truth, the crucial to other symbols also lies in the notion of contrast. For instance, Manuel feels moved by falling snowflakes but it appears that it is, in reality, the notion of some thing appearing and disappearing with such ease that provokes his thoughts. Similarly, he makes a comment to Lazaro contrasting what is steady and what is fleeting, ‘Has visto, Lazaro, misterio mayor que el de la nieve cayendo en el lago y muriendo en l mientras cubre con su toca a la montaa[13]. Hence for Manuel, he finds symbolic which means in things which reflect his lifelong struggle amongst the want to live and a longing for death. Contemplating the use of symbols from a distinction stance, their presence in the novel really serves to show how we can't hope to locate a single truth of which means the symbols arise in the minds of certain characters in particular contexts. They are simply an additional way in which Unamuno keeps the truth about San Manuel just out of our reach.

San Manuel Bueno, martir explores truth in several of its diverse facets. It dwells on the Truth about mortality, the expertise of which is portrayed as a burden as well wonderful for the common man to be in a position to reside with. The novel proposes that religion Catholicism in specific, functions to enable guys to live in contentment. But Unamuno also dwells on the elusive nature of truth in literature simply because anything that is written or spoken will usually be a matter of perception and in this way the reader can never reach a basis of certainty. At a time of political turmoil in Spain, Unamuno’s novel was particularly relevant because it questioned the people’s accessibility to the truth behind public discourse, and also raised queries about the positive aspects and issues with religion and also with the radical progressivism which was shaking Spain to its core in 1930.

[1] M. De Unamuno, San Manuel Bueno, martir. Concentrate Publishing (2004) p25 [two] ibid. p32 [3] M. De Unamuno, Mi Religian y Otros Ensayos Breves. Espasa Calpe (1986) [four] Diario antimo (Madrid: Alianza, 1970) [five] M. De Unamuno, San Manuel Bueno, martir. p6 [six] ibid p6 [7] ibid p46 [eight] ibid. p44 [9] ibid. p45 [ten] M. De Unamuno, Vida de Don Quijote y Sancho, OC, IV, pp.227-8 [11] M. De Unamuno, San Manuel Bueno, martir. p2 [12] ibid p8 [13] ibid p30



DE UNAMUNO, M. San Manuel Bueno, martir (Concentrate Publishing: R Pullins Business, 2004)

BUTT, J. Critical Guides to Spanish Texts No.31, Miguel de Unamuno: San Manuel Bueno, martir (Grant and Cutlet Ltd, 1981)

DE UNAMUNO, M. Vida de Don Quijote y Sancho (Distribooks Poc Edition, February 1987)

DE UNAMUNO, M. Mi Religian y Otros Ensayos Breves (Espasa Calpe, 1986)


SUMMERHILL, S.J. ‘San Manuel Bueno, martir’ and the Reader. In Anales de la literature espaola contempor?nea. Vol.ten, No.1/3 (Society of Spanish and Spanish-American Studies, 1985)

GLANNON, W. Unamuno’s San Manuel Bueno, martir: Ethics by means of Fiction. In Hispanic Concern, Vol.102, No.two (The John Hopkins University Press, March 1987)

LONGHURST, C.A. The Difficulty of Truth in ‘San Manuel Bueno, martir’. In The Modern Language Review, Vol. 76, No. three (Modern day Humanities Analysis Association, July 1981)

GORDON, M. The Elusive Self: Narrative Method and Its Implications in San Manuel Bueno, martir. In Hispanic Review, Vol.54, No.2 (University of Pennsylvania Press, Spring 1986)
Calculate your price
What are you waiting for?
Thousands of students choose us!

Sorry, copying is not allowed on our website. If you want a paper on this sample, we’ll created new for you.

Order Now

Order Now