Published: 23-12-2019

121 writers online

Disclaimer: This essay is not an example of the work done by the EssayPay© service. Samples of our experts work can be found here. All opinions and conclusions belong to the authors, who sent us this essay.
If you want to pay for essay for unique writing Evaluation of the Role of Montresor in Edgar Allan Poe’s Story, The Cask of Amontillado, just click Order button. We will write a custom essay on Evaluation of the Role of Montresor in Edgar Allan Poe’s Story, The Cask of Amontillado specifically for you!

Evaluation of the Role of Montresor in Edgar Allan Poe’s Story, The Cask of Amontillado

Films primarily based on murders are commonplace nowadays, with our society’s obsession with gory violence and sophisticated crimes. In a way we worship the likes of Hannibal Lecter, John Doe, and Norman Bates for their stories’ complex schemes, intense plots, and witty lines, leaving us yearning for more, wanting to see their subsequent victim inhumanely treated and killed. All of these serial killers have psychopathic tendencies, killing out of pleasure and happiness. And we really like it. The insanity of these perpetrators is our bait. At first glance of Edgar Allen Poe’s “The Cask of Amontillado,”the murderer Montresor seems to join the ranks amongst the most vicious criminals however, as soon as the adrenaline of the crime wears, the humane side of the Italian gentleman shows. He becomes ridden with guilt as any particular person with sympathy would. Due to the fact of this glimmer of the true Montresor, we as the readers do not get the effect of a horror story revolving about a psychopathic murderer, but rather a story with a moral: “Think before you do.”

Montresor’s murder conspiracy parallels that of one particular of the most popular and gory horror movies of all time Saw.In Saw, the Jigsaw Killer (the killer in the story) is a terminally ill brain cancer patient whose objective in the remainder of his life is to eradicate all wrongdoing in the world. In the film, all of his victims are individuals he has personally had get in touch with with, such as the protagonists: Adam and Dr. Gordon (the man who treated the Jigsaw Killer). Similarly, Fortunato and Montresor had been acquaintances for very some time and that Fortunatohad committed “a thousand injuries” (Poe 62). In Saw the Jigsaw Killer chains the males in an unused bathroom with no likelihood of escape. The only way to survive is to comply with his directions closely and do everything he demands, like killing each other with poison and cutting their feet off in order to liberate themselves from the chain. In the “Cask of Amontillado,” Montresorvows a violent revenge upon his enemy saying, “I should not only punish, but punish with impunity” (62). The use of impunity implies that Montresor will carefully program his act guaranteeing that he will stay safe and unscathed from the authorities. Montresor’s basic though efficient strategy ensues in the narration. He makes use of a cask of amontillado as his bait and lures a drunk and unwitting Fortunato. Fortunato, with his adore of drink can't refuse this supply and blindly follows his captor into the crypts deep beneath the surface.Eventually, Montresor finds a niche exactly where he chains Fortunato and walls him in, related to the bathroom in “Saw.” Similarly, the murders in each stories give their victims an opportunity to escape. The Jigsaw killer provides Dr. Gordon the choice to kill Adam by 6 o’clock and he will be set cost-free. Montresor repeatedly warns Fortunato the dangers of the cold and damp catacombs inferring that he could become ill. Fortunato, like Dr. Gordon, refuses these possibilities and thus makes it possible for the bloodshed to develop. The similarity among Saw and “Cask of Amontillado” are striking. Both share the same characteristics of a horror movie in which the antagonist grows close to the casualty, providing them salvation just before the kill.

Regardless of the initial resemblance to Saw,the final of feelings of the killers are distinctly opposite. In the film, the Jigsaw killer is calm and practically excited about killing the innocent men and women. In reality he had currently committed a number of murders ahead of the one particular of Adam and Dr. Gordon and continues to do so all through the movie series. Nevertheless, in the “Cask of Amontillado” a flicker of guilt is clearly observed in Montresor. Ahead of laying the final brick of the wall to rest, Montresor cries out Fortunato’s name to no avail. He tries it once again,


No answer. I known as again—


No answer nevertheless. I thrust a torch through the remaining aperture and let it fall within. There came forth in return only a jingling of the bells. My heart grew sick – on account of the Catacombs. (67-8)

It is clear to the reader that Montresor’s heart was not sick simply because of the Catacombs, but rather because he had realized the severity of his actions. The hesitation conveys a sense of self-reassurance of Montresor, who is telling himself that his actions were not horrific, but rather the setting was creating the nausea. Since of this guilt, “The Cask of Amontillado” can not be classified in the genre of horror because the killer feels guilt in his murder. In reality, adrenaline drove Montresor to commit the crime, and as opposed to the Jigsaw Killer, he regretted his actions.

Since “The Cask of Amontillado” can no longer be classified as a horror movie,

due to the guilt of Montresor, the theme and genre of the story is drastically changed. Poe’s work now fits the blueprint of a parable, or a story with a moral. Throughout Poe’s life, the Temperance Crusade was very popular. Its objective was to generate an alcohol prohibition in the United States, and succeeded in performing so in the state of Maine. Poe’s intention could have been to warn the reader of the dangers of alcohol and the poor choices connected with drinking. A drunken Fortunato was effortlessly convinced to adhere to his captor baited by a lot more alcohol. Nevertheless, this does not clarify the feelings of Montresor, which had been so clearly present and strong. Alternatively, Poe was attempting to reinforce an age-old moral: “think before you do.” One particular could argue that Montresor had precisely planned his scheme, and consequently he had thought cautiously about his actions. However, this can be explained by the adrenaline. Adrenaline enables for excessive concentrate, power, and excitement. Montresor was so overcome with adrenaline for the duration of his crime that he did not take into account the repercussions of his actions. Instead of Fortunato getting blindly led by Montresor, it was in reality Montresor being blindly led by adrenaline. As Montresor lifted the final brick, preparing to seal the wall for eternity, he hesitated as he reflected on the circumstance. As he yelled out Fortunato’s name, the effect of adrenaline had ended and the proceeding actions were all benefits of conscious choices. Realizing that he had come also far and there was no turning back, Montresor had no choice but to finish the wall and steer clear of getting charged with crime. Therefore, Edgar Allen Poe was not attempting to create a story that would scare the reader, but rather one particular that would influence their choices.

Despite the similarities in the beginning with the film “Saw,” “The Cask of Amontillado”lacks an antagonist that enjoys the act of murder in order to be classified as a horror or thriller movie like Saw. Alternatively it can be categorized as a parable, a story with a moral. Edgar Allen Poe wrote this story to remind the reader to usually feel prior to actually performing the action. In some scenarios adrenaline will override your selection-generating much like alcohol would (a frequent dilemma at the time). The hormone adrenaline is typically referred to as the “fight or flight” response, which means it causes involuntary actions to happen with out the brain obtaining to method the stimulus. In this case, the adrenaline impaired Montresor’s capacity to method his actions. Poe selects a distinct approach of teaching rather than merely stating his thesis, he tells us in a creative way. It is extraordinary how significantly situational variables effect our selection-producing. It is essential, as folks, to be conscious of our atmosphere and that we do not put ourselves in situations in which our judgment could not be well advised.
Calculate your price
What are you waiting for?
Thousands of students choose us!

Sorry, copying is not allowed on our website. If you want a paper on this sample, we’ll created new for you.

Order Now

Order Now